We are proud to announce our NEW community destination. Engage with resident experts and fellow entrepreneurs, and learn everything you need to start your business. Check out the new home of StartupNation Community at startupnation.mn.co

Anyone with experience with Design Patents

callegarimcallegarim subscriber Posts: 4
edited October 2014 in Protecting Your Ideas
I've been researching how to protect my product idea, and have narrowed it down to only one possibility - the design patent. 
It's been a challenge to digest and comprehend exactly how a product can get a design patent. 
After reading a number of articles, talking with legalzoom.com's people, and examining the actual US laws about design patents I'm still very unsure of what qualifies.
I understand you CAN'T just take a product, paint it a different color and patent it as a new product... BUT If you take an existing product and add an "original" and "ornamental" design to it this somehow qualifies.
The example I read that was the easiest to understand was a clock face. You can patent an original clock face design with a design patent, but what if you were the first person to create a line of neon colored clocks? Or you created the first line of clock faces with various patterns (stripes, plaid, multicolored, ect)? This is very similar to the product I'm trying to create. It's an existing product that only exists in black or silver. I know a new line of vibrantly colored, and uniquly designed versions of this product would sell/get licensed to major retailers, but can I protect this from getting knocked off overnight?
Does anyone have any experience with design patents?

Thanks in advance for any help!

- Matt
The quote from Legalzoom.com's design patent requirements: 

 Generally, a design must satisfy the following to be patentable:

It is "part" of the article. That is, the design is intertwined and inseparable from the item. For example, the label design on a bottle would not qualify, but the bottle itself could, if uniquely shaped, and as long as that shape does not affect the bottle's function.
It is purely ornamental. The design cannot be responsible for the article's function, including new or improved use. A good test is to ask, "Would the article work the same way if the design were removed or changed?" If the answer is that removing the design would not alter the function, then you are in the realm of the design patent. If the item would work differently (or not at all) with the design element removed, the design will not qualify for design patent protection (but may qualify for a utility patent).

To return to the bottle example above, if the new shape enables spill-proof pouring, this would be a functional change pointing toward a utility patent.
The law also requires a patentable design to be "original" (cannot simulate a well-known or naturally occurring object or person, and cannot be obvious in light of pre-existing designs) as well as not offensive to any race, religion, sex, ethnic group or nationality.


  • HashHash subscriber Posts: 1 Member
    My question is along these lines. I'm new here, so Hello everyone!!

    In a rough explanation, let's say I buy a bunch of Lego's. I want to arrange them in different patterns and sell the pieces as works of art, or whatever. What can I do to protect myself from someone else who wants to take this idea, come up with their own designs, and sell it. (This is ignoring any restrictions the Lego company many have in place about reselling their product).

    Thank you! I look forward to your responses!
  • AriannaPhillipsAriannaPhillips subscriber Posts: 1 Member
    Design patent is a patent granted for the protection of the ornament or art alone. It does not protect the utility of the inventions. A design is compose of visual ornamental characteristics embodied in, or applied to, an article of manufacture.

    Designs can be considered unique if they have different shapes and appearance. When it comes to surface ornamentation applied to the article, the ornamentation must be inseparable to the article or cannot exist alone.
Sign In or Register to comment.