Which design is better

redfish

Hi,
Can you tell me which design you like better
http://www.redfishbluefishdesign.com/redesign/
http://www.redfishbluefishdesign.com/redesign2
My graphic design artist is leaning toward the first redesign - however our logo is that of the second design.  Should I change our logo (is the improvement that good?)  We`re a newer company, so I don`t want to have that many changes... we`re just building our brand and name in our community - a change might not help it...
Impressions on graphics, and whether to make a logo change or not are both welcome!
Thanks
Jeff

vwebworld

#2 better
 
... what about having the fish graphic behind the text rather than over it (blocking it)?
 
~Roland

redfish

my thoughts exactly. But I wanted to get second (third, fourth and any other that may come) opinions as we`ve had a differing thoughts.